I started watching Alien: Earth and I’m already disenchanted with it. I am a fan of the franchise, and I consider the original Alien a classic in the horror genre, but this iteration is just not really appealing to me, yet.
I’m just tired of the bad corporation trope in general. I know that Weyland-Yutani is the big bad in the films – even way back to the original movie, but I would have liked to have anyone else, anything else to be the protagonist. Or no protagonist – have it all be a messy industrial accident. Anything but a corporation that seems to delight in corporate malfeasance.
I’m also tired of the ‘corporations run the world’ trope as well. Again, I know it’s a cornerstone of dystopic sci-fi, but it’s also been done to death. I know that this trope has historical precedent, but let’s not go for the low hanging fruit? Besides – you really think the government is going to let these companies run as rampant as they’re depicted in most dystopian sci-fi? No one is going to give up power. Share? Sure – but knowing that the first sign of weakness is going to be the signal to take them out.
The beauty of the xenomorph is that it is an animal at the end of the day. It is unthinking, unfeeling force of nature. It doesn’t care about your stock portfolio, it doesn’t want conquest. It wants to feed and procreate. No matter how advanced we get in this particular universe, it doesn’t care. It will terrify us, humble us, and it does it with no emotion. That’s the horror of the movie – dying because you were in the wrong place a the wrong time. The xenomorph has no agenda.
Another trope that figures in the show – and can be traced back to the original movie – is the malicious robot. I know, I know: the robot can only do what it’s programmed to do. It’s not evil, it’s made that way. Are you telling me that the world of Aliens had no one stand up and say: “I’ve been reading this Asimov guy…and I think he’s got some good ideas about programming robots.” Even roboticists nowadays are programming – hard coding – the Three Laws of Robotics into systems. I’m ready to see man’s inhumanity to man again.
I know I’m knocking at the main tropes in this show, and the franchise in general, but it can be really good if they head in different directions. I liked Aliens 3 because it was different. No Marines. No scientists. Just man versus nature.
That’s what I want in my movie, but who am I to argue?
